Turtle Ice Cream Pie

Hi folks!

Okay if you’re new…

I love Turtles!

If you’re not new….

I love Turtles!

It’s an obsession!

The only thing that rivals it is my obsession with the one and only…

Timothy Olyphant!

Yup, both equally yummy.

Okay that’s not true.

Timothy is way yummier than Turtles!

But don’t tell the Turtles company I said that!

Okay this is not really so much a recipe as a guide. Or how to. Or how not to if you’re dieting. And let’s be honest, if you’re dieting why the h…e…double hockey sticks are you here??? Hmm, you’re dirty little secret is out. You love sugar, You looovvvee it, You lovvvveee suuugarrr!

Okay I am done now. Enjoy! Peace out sugar lovers!


Turtle Ice Cream Pie
Recipe type: Dessert, Ice Cream
  • 1 cup oreo crumbs
  • 3 tablespoons butter, melted
  • ½ cup skor bits
  • ½ cup pecan bits
  • 4 ginormous scoops of Turtle Ice Cream
  • ¼ cup caramel sauce
  • ¼ cup hot fudge sauce
  • 4 Turtles candy
  1. In a small bowl combine crumbs and butter. Mix well.
  2. Take that and spoon into 4 individual size pie pans or spring form pans.
  3. Bake those in a preheated 350 degree oven for 8 to 10 minutes.
  4. Remove and let cool.
  5. Crush you pecans.
  6. Now take place one huge scoop of ice cream in each pan.
  7. Toss your skor bits and pecans over top.
  8. Drizzle with heated up caramel sauce and hot fudge sauce.
  9. Top each with a Turtles candy.
  10. Enjoy and gain 10 pounds.
  11. Don't say I didn't warn you.
  12. Best enjoyed while watching Timothy Olyphant movies.
  13. Just sayin'!


Yup you know you love me now! I kinda love me too! And Timothy! Just sayin’!

Other Turtle recipes by moi:

Turtle Bark
Turtle Ice Cream
Turtle Banana Split

and coming soon:

Turtle Popcorn

Toodles and smoochies! xx

Get More Updates!

Sign up to get exclusive updates & tips!


  1. Nami | Just One Cookbook says

    You are killing me with everything Turtle! You know how much I loved your Turtle bark…and Turtle recipe still continues. I HEART this ice cream pie!

  2. Curry and Comfort says

    LOL!! Yes.. you got it out of me… my secret is out… I'm a suggggarr lover!! :) This looks decadent and yummy!! So COUNT ME the "H-E-double hockey sticks" IN! ~ Ramona

  3. The Mom Chef says

    How bad is it that I had to go look up who Timothy Olyphant is. Yeah, he's cute. Turtles are yummy if they're heavy on the caramel especially. Since this is a pie and I put it together how I want, it would be heavy on the caramel and so it would be megalicious. :)

  4. Dara Reppucci says

    Kim I just want to come over to your house and eat everything! Between this and the chocolate cake popcorn I am craving chocolate right now.

  5. janet@fromcupcakestocaviar says

    And yet one more thing to cement our twindom is the Turtle Love… you can keep Timothy though.

    You can't however keep this pie… hand it over and no Olyphants will get hurt….

  6. Kim Bee says

    Oh my, you are missing out. Watch the romcom called Catch and Release, my fave Tim movie. Jennifer Garner is in it too. Great movie. And The Perfect Getaway, so good in it! See this pie was made just for you!

  7. Kim Bee says

    I swear it's bad though. I need to drop weight and it happening with all these goodies around calling out my name in the middle of the night.

  8. Kim Bee says

    Ah man you are gonna have to get used to the dude. He's going to be my boytoy when we marry. My Mister-ess if you will.

  9. Kiri W. says

    Kim, Kim, Kim. Why would you do this to me? Have I ever been cruel and seductive to you? No? Well.
    Mmmmmmmmm. Please drop an order off at my place soon 😉

  10. Emily says

    I feel like I have already added a few inches to my hips by reading this but you know what? I will take it. Delicious!

  11. Alyssa says

    I think I gained 10lbs just from looking at this (or do Canadian's use Kilos?) That looks amazing even for someone like me who doesn't really have a sweet tooth. I do love "turtle" desserts though because of the combination of salty and sweet.

  12. Kim Bee says

    I use pounds and trust me I am feeling the same way. I really need to stop eating like an 8 year old. But it's just so fun.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.